We have so far had a couple of questions of the form "is 'X' constitutional?" (as applied to USA). Ex: Is the PATRIOT ACT constitutional?
Should such questions be in scope at all?
The cons include the fact that there are only 2 kinds of answers: "Nobody knows until SCOTUS rules on it" or "Yes as per SCOTUS case ABC".
The caveat is that the 'X' in question may not neatly align to existing SCOTUS rulings.
The pros include the fact that there are only 2 possible good answers (see the cons) - "Yes" (include proof) and "Nobody knows".
If not, is there any way that such a question can be salvaged? (if you claim that "yes", please provide an example edit of how to make the above Patriot Act question salvageable).