5

has 17 questions, has 36 questions. They are basically the same, so it makes sense to make one the synonym of the other.

  • What's the process for retagging/burnination here? It's been a week with no downvotes or disagreement: are there certain positive criteria we should wait for before making the change (time, # upvotes)? – divibisan Apr 17 at 18:13
  • @divibisan not sure, though there have been only a few votes. We could ping in chat or something. Oh and those with enough rep in the tag can propose and vote manually, I think. – JJJ Apr 17 at 21:01
  • I see no reason not to move forward with this, but I don't have sufficient score in the tag to suggest a synonym – divibisan Sep 25 at 22:22
  • @divibisan same situation, I think this is one of these situations where executive power is needed. ;) – JJJ Sep 25 at 22:50
2

The whole set of tags for the 3 typical branches of a government with separation of powers is a bit chaotic:

The separation of powers into 3 branches is AFAIK not specific to the United States but rather specific to most democratic republics (in fact the US isn't even the purest example, because the executive branch has some legislative power in form of the presidential veto). But on the other hand, there are also less democratic governments in the world which do not have a separation into distinct branches, but all governments have executive, legislative and judiciary functions.

So what I did is the following:

  1. Made a synonym of
  2. Renamed to
4

I agree that they should be synonyms, but wouldn't it be better the other way?

I've always though of "Judicial Branch" being specifically American, as a reference to the 3 branches of government. I've never heard it used for another country. Would you really talk about the Judicial Branch of the UK?

is definitely more common and is definitely the more general and country-independent term.

  • Thanks, I removed that part of my question (it hadn't been voted on much so I can get away with it). You make a convincing argument so I changed the title too. – JJJ Apr 11 at 11:36
  • "Would you really talk about the Judicial Branch of the UK?" No we wouldn't, because in the UK the judiciary and legislature are not regarded as branches of the government. Indeed, the official name of the executive here is "Her Majesty's Government" - and it refers only to the executive. – Steve Melnikoff Sep 26 at 10:00
  • @SteveMelnikoff No, you’re right. That’s why I suggested that The US specific Judicial-branch be made a synonym of the more general Judiciary instead of the other way around – divibisan Sep 26 at 14:03
  • @divibisan: yup; I agree! – Steve Melnikoff Sep 26 at 14:04

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .