9

There is already the use of the tags and and I wanted to ask whether anybody else sees a problem with using them.

Personally I think because there is no clear definition of "left" and "right" (see What is meant by the “left” and the “right”?) we should not be using the tags. This could lead to a lot of discussion whether an issue or a question is adequately tagged.

I would move to ban those two tags.

5

I say nuke em!

I am a horribly biased libertarian in that respect, but they are however a fairly useless binary classification in many cases.

And you don't want people fighting over which one belongs with certain topics (cough National Socialism) either, if such things happen to come up.

(Edit: Oops, didn't notice they were both already on a question about that.)

5

Based on the answers here, I've merged and synonymized both with . This'll both prevent them from coming back into use, and (hopefully) represent the true intentions of those using them.

1

Maybe we should move to (and possibly synonymise to) a tag to which they collectively belong... I can't think of the exact word at the moment but something like though I know there's a better word for it...

  • That occurred to me too ... I don't think leaning is discoverable enough, though (perhaps a question on ux.se is in order). Maybe wing, with right and left as synonyms? – user97 Dec 11 '12 at 9:33
0

I'll steal an idea from @Graham, and propose "" instead.

And burninate any questions that don't use Nolan Matrix instead of left-rite axis (j/k :))))

-2

The main problem I can see with banning and is that some useful questions are likely to come up regarding their use and meaning, beyond the one linked to in the question. Neither tag has seen a lot of use so far, and I think both questions that have employed it:

... are good ones.

For the time being, I'd be in favour of leaving the tags alone (and maybe revisiting the issue if we do have problems down the line).

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .