36 votes

Why did the question "Is President Donald Trump a racist?" get closed?

I have been a moderator on this site for quite a while and am pretty active on the site myself. So I think I have quite a lot of experience with how the community reacts to certain questions. Let me ...
Philipp's user avatar
  • 76.8k
26 votes

Why did the question "Is President Donald Trump a racist?" get closed?

I agree with SamIAm that your question is too meta, and because of that seems to promote a specific cause, which is off-topic (I would disagree with Philipp, that a potentially on-topic question can/...
tim's user avatar
  • 37k
22 votes
Accepted

How do I prove my question is asked in good faith?

I don't think you can every prove good faith – no matter what rules or advice we give, there will be concern trolls who are happy to abuse them. I think the best thing you can do is interact with the ...
divibisan's user avatar
  • 25.9k
12 votes

How should questions that seem anti-Semitic be handled?

Part of the problem has been people Sealioning (a type of bad-faith) the issue on multiple sites. In Charcoal (anti-spam project) we track mentions of the Holocaust. An excellent example happened here ...
Machavity's user avatar
  • 48.3k
12 votes
Accepted

When are media sources considered propaganda and the questions citing them will be closed?

No, I did not claim that any of these websites are propaganda. I claimed that they reported on a claim which is propaganda. If you read the articles carefully, you will notice that they do not report ...
Philipp's user avatar
  • 76.8k
11 votes

Closed within 30 minutes

General principles rather than having any chance to improve my question, it is closed. Closing is a chance to improve your question before it is answered. Once a question is answered, your ...
Brythan's user avatar
  • 89.6k
11 votes

What exactly makes this question not "a good faith effort" etc.?

I did not find the post/Q incredibly biased; some puns aside you've done a decent effort of presenting both sides of an argument. But consider what you're ultimately asking: Was it really about ...
the gods from engineering's user avatar
10 votes

Is there a way to get information on my closed and deleted questions and answers?

A desire for revenge is not tolerated on this site, @guest271314. Instead of focusing oneself on hurting other users who voted to close posts, one should see if these posts can be improved. Other ...
Be Brave Be Like Ukraine's user avatar
10 votes
Accepted

How can I improve this question?

The most immediate problem with your post is that it violates some basic rules of Composition and Style. These aren't Stack Exchange rules per se, they're good practices for writing in general. Get ...
Sam I am says Reinstate Monica's user avatar
10 votes

Why did the question "Is President Donald Trump a racist?" get closed?

I'm going to go ahead and post some of my thoughts on the question in question, specifically, where it might have problems. The majority of your question is a meta-commentary about other questions. ...
Sam I am says Reinstate Monica's user avatar
10 votes

Why has my question as to why the Allies did not discuss a Homeland for Jewish people in Germany been closed?

I responded to your question after it received a rude or abusive flag. I don't think it is rude per se, but I found two other issues: The question is about history, not politics. In the comments you ...
JJJ's user avatar
  • 39.1k
9 votes

How should questions that seem anti-Semitic be handled?

Frankly I don't think there's much to be gained by closing a question just because it questions a practice that people consider to be racist. As long as they're not maliciously disparaging anyone or ...
Sam I am says Reinstate Monica's user avatar
9 votes

Repeatedly closing and reopening of (highly) controversial questions

I haven't read the question, but FWIW -9 downvotes (and counting), and zero upvotes, is a sign that the question isn't controversial at all. Only troll types of questions get that type of verdict. ...
Denis de Bernardy's user avatar
9 votes
Accepted

Confused by the 'reopen' process

The wording is confusing, but reopen votes and the reopen review queue are actually 2 separate things. A question gets reopened when it gets sufficient reopen votes. To enable improved or improperly ...
divibisan's user avatar
  • 25.9k
9 votes
Accepted

Why was my question on politics SE completely rewritten?

I guess I am the one you are referring to who "edited it so much that it no longer resembles the original in any shape or form". That is somewhat true. The intention was ofcourse, to be ...
sfxedit's user avatar
  • 9,024
9 votes

Is there freedom of speech here?

Two points: "Freedom of speech" in the legal sense only applies to government suppression of speech or communicative acts. The US, European, and most industrialized nation governments do ...
Ted Wrigley's user avatar
  • 69.1k
8 votes
Accepted

Apparent close votes discrepancy

There are two ways to cast close votes on a question (for users with sufficient privileges, of course): via the review queue by clicking on "close" below the question itself The close-votes cast via ...
Philipp's user avatar
  • 76.8k
8 votes
Accepted

Repeatedly closing and reopening of (highly) controversial questions

I'd just let the 'roller coaster' do its thing because that seems to be entirely by design. There are certain time limits to the close votes so the roller coaster won't go on infinitely (at least not ...
JJJ's user avatar
  • 39.1k
8 votes

Why was this on-topic question closed for being off-topic?

Welcome to Politics Stack Exchange. Please note that the purpose of this website is to teach and learn about politics and political processes. We are not here to convince others of our political views ...
Philipp's user avatar
  • 76.8k
8 votes
Accepted

Is there a way the closed question on "protests against Amy Barrett" be opened again?

I reopened it. I added the summary-request tag because you're asking about background information for protests against this specific nominee. As such, I think it's the scope is sufficiently narrowed ...
JJJ's user avatar
  • 39.1k
8 votes
Accepted

Is re-asking a bad question in a better way allowed?

If the original question is unsalvageable (closed, heavily downvoted, perhaps even deleted) then this can be a good course of action. Sometimes the original question might have a valid core-question, ...
Philipp's user avatar
  • 76.8k
8 votes

Why has my question on a 4 day working week been closed down as off-topic?

In the (likely) case the Q gets deleted, it asked: what I want to ask would a four day workimg week work in the USA? Or are people there married to their jobs there rather than their wives - it never ...
the gods from engineering's user avatar
7 votes
Accepted

Please reopen this question on policymaking in Japan

As I mentioned in a comment under the question, I think it's still too broad even when narrowed down to a single country: @Matcha_boy98 it's still pretty broad. How a country makes policy is quite ...
JJJ's user avatar
  • 39.1k
7 votes

Why are we closing questions for being susceptible to opinion on a site about politics?

What was your goal in asking the question? (really think about this one) What do you think an acceptable answer to this question should include? Do you already have you mind made up about the ...
bobsburner's user avatar
7 votes

Why was my question on Male Genital Mutilation closed as a duplicate?

There was a comment by the initial close-voter; I can't remember it exactly, but it was to the effect of: The UK and US are similar enough politically that the answer will be the same. ...
F1Krazy's user avatar
  • 3,392
7 votes

Why didn't the FBI monitor bankrupt (former) employees more watchfully?

Almost any question that begins with "why" is asking people to explain the motivations of other people. I.e. it is soliciting opinion and speculation, and therefore "off-topic". Here, and in general ...
Ray Butterworth's user avatar
6 votes

A question was put on hold. Can I ask you why?

The question had issues to begin with. Note that putting a question on hold is not a rejection of that question. It means that the question still has issues which need to be resolved before ...
Philipp's user avatar
  • 76.8k
6 votes

Why was this question closed?

There are two kinds of aspects to building a canal. The engineering aspects. Is it possible to build a canal from A to B? What would it cost? How long would it take? What physical obstacles are there ...
Philipp's user avatar
  • 76.8k
6 votes

Closure of Qatar question on their policy to pay western sources

If you are among the 5 that closed, can you elaborate on why you did so? Not making much sense, at least to me. If I recall correctly, I voted to close for the following reason: Questions asking ...
JJJ's user avatar
  • 39.1k
6 votes

Why are some questions which are clearly opinion-based allowed while others are not?

For the questions in your post: Why is President Trump making such a big deal about fake news, and specifically targeting reputable organizations like The New York Times and CNN? While the wording ...
reirab's user avatar
  • 8,261

Only top scored, non community-wiki answers of a minimum length are eligible